Unfortunately, the one I received had a few marks and many tiny but deep scratches right out of the box which were under the protective plastic, so they couldn't be seen before taking it off. Disappointing of course, but at this price point just unacceptable.
Also disappointed that there is no shielding underneath the pickguard whatsoever. That wasn't advertised, so I guess I shouldn't be mentioning it, but for the price I don't think it's unreasonable to expect at least a small piece of aluminum tape.
Only positives I can say are that it's a perfect fit for a Player Telecaster, and the edges of the pickguard are the smoothest I've seen.
I knew this pickguard wasn't great value compared to alternative offerings, but I wanted official parts for my guitar that I really like. If I had known high price doesn't guarantee quality, I would've just saved some money and bought from another brand instead.
